Where English teachers go to help each other
Contemporary Fiction Graphic Novel
I'm looking for a Graphic Novel to use in my Contemporary Fiction class. Any ideas? These are seniors but are reluctant learners age 17-21.
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Thomas Roddy, Jr. on -
I think a great Graphic Novel is American Born Chinese. It has wonderful themes about identity and myth. My very reluctant readers loved it.
-
Permalink Reply by YAGoodBadUgly on -
I love that one. I think that might be what I go with but i was wondering if there are other gems i'm missing!
-
Permalink Reply by glenda funk on -
I teach MAUS and MAUS to seniors and also really like "Pride of Baghdad." You might also take a look at the graphic novel version of "Beowuld."
-
Permalink Reply by Russ Weems on -
Look for my reply in the Resistance to Graphic Novels thread that has a pdf attachment of my syllabus of the Introduction to Graphic Literature course that I just started teaching as a full year graphic literature course to seniors. The novels mentioned below are good, particularly Maus and Pride of Baghdad. Persepolis was also well received, as well as Watchmen. Look through it and I will give you some ideas on what worked and didn't work this year.
-
Permalink Reply by Phil Huff on -
Here's a couple of 'mainstream' titles to look for.
Batman-The Dark Knight Returns by Frank Miller. On par with The Watchmen, as one of the first great graphic novels. This is a mature disturbing, and thrilling re-working of the Batman Legend. The characters are familiar, especially with the current films, but taken in new directions. Highly Recommended.
The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen by Alan Moore. First of all, if you've seen or heard of the atrocious film version, forget it. It is nothing like the original work. Alan Quatermain, Dr. Jeckyl, Captain Nemo, The Invisible Man, and Mina Murray (recently divorced from her husband Jonathan Harker) are recruited by Campion Bond (James' great grandfather) to serve the British Empire when needed. Victorian-era literary characters make frequent guest appearances, which adds to the fun if you know who they are. Even if reader's don't, this is one of the best adventures ever set to print.
-
Permalink Reply by glenda funk on
-
A podcast describing recently published graphic novels is available at Read, Write, Think. It's episode 15, Under "Podcasts for Ages 11-18."
http://www.readwritethink.org/beyondtheclassroom/summer/podcastsvid...
-
Permalink Reply by Forrest Helvie on -
A couple of good suggestions already made (and one or two not yet suggested) are:
Maus
Persepolis
Pride of Baghdad
Watchmen
V for Vendetta
I debated about Marvel Comics' "Civil War" mini series as it makes a great launching point to discuss many current events such as the Patriot Act and other political, hot-bed issues. The one snag to using this is that I COULD foresee a problem with students "entering" into a pre-established world of the Marvel Universe, and if they aren't already familiar with it, there could be some problems with missing some of the finer details of the story.
You might also try splitting the class in half with one group working on the Hinds' rendition of "Beowulf" (which is supposed to be truer to the original text) and the Neil Gaiman edition which is what the movie was based on. You could have the two reading groups present to the class how their text handles each part of the story and the differences might make for some interesting discussion.
Best of luck!
-
Permalink Reply by Russ Weems on
-
One great activity I found with using Hind's "Beowulf" is to take Seamus Heaney's translation of "Beowulf" and have them sketch the panels from the Hind's rendition of the battle between Beowulf and Grendel, then to find quotes from the text that correspond to the scenes drawn (the battle is presented with no words at all). It really gets them to appreciate how an artist converts words to art, how a picture can truly speak a thousand words. I'm sure it would work with other translations (I think Hind specifies which translation he used to create the book).
In regards to the Marvel issue, I had that concern when I used the books "Marvels" by Kurt Busiek and Alex Ross, and "Kingdom Come" by Mark Waid and Alex Ross. I each case, I had them do some quick research on major Marvel and DC characters respectively before reading and look for those characters and elements as they read. No, they won't get all of the pre-established universe's nuances, but they will get some, and there are bound to be comic aficionados in the class who would be happy to enlighten others.
-
Permalink Reply by Jeraldine Kraver on -
Take a look at the gorgeous _The Rabbi's Cat_ by Joann Sfar.
Also, _The Arrival_ (Shaun Tan) is a curious take on the mode, but it's provocative and really asks students to "create" a narrative.
-
Permalink Reply by Jeraldine Kraver on
-
Here's a link to a review of Tan's book by Gene Luen Yang (of _Americn Born Chinese_)
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/11/11/books/review/Yang-t.html
About
Latest Activity
Hi Pat, I have never done these myself, but there are some great examples at VocabAhead Vocab Videos which also contains links to digital resources to help students create their videos. While most of the videos are done professionally, there is at l…
Thanks for your reply -- it was very helpful. I think I understand what you are saying -- kids do try to craft a dazzling sentence, rather than one with insight. And something simple can be insightful. But my concern is really the thinking behind th…
I would say comedy is underrepresented. My students have nicknamed my class "AP Sex & Death" as we tend to go to the dark side. I do try to use some comedy in preparation for a Q3 comedy prompt. We do use A Midsummer Night's Dream, The Color Purple…
Your "rambling" is fantastic. So much good advice. You know, I'm actually looking forward to writing now. I feel like I've got a handle on it.
Thanks for all of your comments.
I really like "Out of the Dust" by Karen Hesse. It is short and I think very accessible for struggling students. It won the Newberry Medal. Not only did it help me understand what the big deal was about the duststorms of the time, I thought it told…
And what about the fact that often writers don't know what their thesis is until they begin reflecting in writing about a subject or occurrence? Happens to me all the time.
Thank you so much everyone! I definitely have a better feel for how essential questions work. I've been able to brainstorm a few and included a few here. Feel free to tell me if I am way off base.
What does it mean to be an “Outsider”?
What makes…
Judith--
One opportunity is Teen Ink (http://www.teenink.com). This is a publication for teens only, ages 13-19, to submit and publish their work. The one draw back I found is that once accepted, Teen Ink keeps all rights to the work. This means ki…
Bill,
You have it wrong. I didn't say the theory has not had wide influence. I never said anything like that. I agree that it has had wide influence. What I said was I've never heard of teachers labeling themselves as constructivists or nonconstruct…
The Ugly Truth is that my number one goal for my students right now has to be to raise their 2010 standardized test scores.
I find it disturbing, off-base, heart-wrenching, and almost something shameful to admit. However, NCLB has my entire school'…
I am in search of a novel set during the Great Depression/Dust Bowl era. It will be used in a 10th grade history class; most of the students are struggling readers. The teacher would like to stay away from the "big name classics." He wants something…
Yay Doug! He was one of my teachers in pre-teaching grad school (itp.nyu.edu), and I'm a huge fan of his work. Thanks for posting this, Frank. I'm really excited to see what these guys have come up with this time.
I am looking for opportunities for high school students to publish their writing. I am in VT. We are part of the NWP and can certainly offer that to our students. I know about the Mountain Review, but I would really appreciate other venues where stu…
Oh, a marvelous poem, Carol -- by one of my favorite poets. In graduate school far back in the 60's, I took a creative writing class from Bly at the University of Kansas, and have never forgotten it. Thanks for the connection.
Badge
© 2010 Created by Jim Burke on Ning. Create a Ning Network!
